Best Home Remodeling Contractors in Middleton, WI (2026)
Choosing the right home remodeling contractor in Middleton, WI can be overwhelming. With 16 home remodeling contractors operating across the Middleton metro area, how do you separate the truly exceptional from the merely adequate? At The Home Remodeling Guide, we analyze publicly available data to rank every home remodeling contractor on a transparent, editorial basis -- no paid placements, no sponsored rankings.
This 2026 ranking evaluates home remodeling contractors in Middleton, Wisconsin using our proprietary Guide Score algorithm, which weighs verified reviews, professional credentials, press recognition, web presence, years of experience, and profile completeness. We reviewed 16 active businesses in the Middleton market and selected the top 15 for this list.
By the numbers: Guide Scores on this list range from 10 to 14 out of 100, 2 of 15 hold professional certifications. Updated April 2026.
Each entry below includes the business's Guide Score, star rating, review count, and a data-driven explanation of why they earned their spot. Click through to any profile for the full breakdown including contact information, specialties, credentials, and related businesses in Middleton.
The Top 15 Home Remodeling Contractors in Middleton, WI
-
#1 Cards Property Maintenance 14/100
Selected for specializes in quick links, our services, contact us.
Cards Property Maintenance is a contractor proudly serving Middleton, WI. Reach them at +6087220709 or email cardspropertymaintenance1@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. L…
View full profile → -
#2 Stagecoach Plumbing, Inc. 13/100
Selected for Licensed certified; specializes in emergency plumbing, residential plumbing services, new construction plumbing.
Stagecoach Plumbing, Inc. is a Middleton-based contractor offering comprehensive services to clients across WI. Their services include emergency plumbing, residential plumbing services, new construct…
View full profile → -
#3 Madison Fence Company 13/100
Ranked 3rd among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Based in Middleton, WI, Madison Fence Company provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 7912 Forsythia Ct. Reach them at +160…
View full profile → -
#4 Dallman Plumbing LLC 12/100
Selected for Licensed certified.
Dallman Plumbing LLC has built a reputation for quality contracting work in the Middleton, WI area. Located at 2211 Parview Rd 5. Reach them at 6088411264. Visit their website for more details on ser…
View full profile → -
#5 Struck & Irwin Fence 12/100
Ranked 5th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Struck & Irwin Fence is an established contractor serving the Middleton, WI community with professional contracting services. Located at 2830 Parmenter St. Reach them at 6082551673. Visit their websi…
View full profile → -
#6 DuraShield Roofing & Contracting 12/100
Ranked 6th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
DuraShield Roofing & Contracting, a contractor in Middleton, WI, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Reach them at 6082213700. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 7…
View full profile → -
#7 Parks Electrical Service Inc 12/100
Ranked 7th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Parks Electrical Service Inc serves Middleton and surrounding WI communities with professional contracting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 7411 Voss Pkwy. Reach them at 608836555…
View full profile → -
#8 Aspen Contracting 11/100
Ranked 8th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Based in Middleton, WI, Aspen Contracting provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 5304 Valley Ridge Plz. Reach them at +160…
View full profile → -
#9 Larson Electric 11/100
Ranked 9th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
As a contractor in Middleton, Larson Electric works with clients across the WI region. Reach them at +16082184522 or email info@larsonelectricmadison.com. Visit their website to learn more about thei…
View full profile → -
#10 McGarrity Painting LLC 11/100
Ranked 10th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Based in Middleton, WI, McGarrity Painting LLC provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 6726 North Ave. Reach them at +16085…
View full profile → -
#11 Access Door & More 11/100
Ranked 11th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Access Door & More, a contractor in Middleton, WI, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Reach them at +16082206571 or email accessdoorwi@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about thei…
View full profile → -
#12 Butler Landscaping 11/100
Ranked 12th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Serving homeowners and businesses in Middleton, Butler Landscaping is a dependable contractor in WI. Reach them at +17342721677 or email thebutlerlandscaping.service@gmail.com. Visit their website to…
View full profile → -
#13 Superior Fence & Rail 10/100
Ranked 13th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Superior Fence & Rail brings professional contracting expertise to the Middleton, WI community. Located at 1600 N High Point Rd Ste 140. Reach them at 6084402889. Visit their website for more details…
View full profile → -
#14 Premier Painting and Contracting 10/100
Ranked 14th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Premier Painting and Contracting is a contractor firm serving Middleton and surrounding areas in WI. Reach them at +16083353335. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1402 Sh…
View full profile → -
#15 Alonso Landscape Service LLC 10/100
Ranked 15th among home remodeling contractors in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Alonso Landscape Service LLC is a trusted contractor proudly serving Middleton, WI and the surrounding region. Located at 2503 Pleasant View Rd. Reach them at 6083084908. Visit their website for more…
View full profile →
How We Ranked These Home Remodeling Contractors
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines verified Google reviews and ratings (30%), professional credentials (10%), press and media recognition (5%), web and portfolio presence (15%), years of experience (15%), profile completeness (10%), and industry awards (up to 5 bonus points). No business can pay for a higher ranking.
Data sources include Google Business Profile, professional registries, portfolio sites, press databases, and direct business submissions. Every piece of data is publicly verifiable.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did we rank the best home remodeling contractors in Middleton?
The Home Remodeling Guide ranks home remodeling contractors using our Guide Score (0-100), a composite metric computed from publicly available data. The score weighs Google reviews and ratings (30%), professional credentials and certifications (10%), press and media recognition (5%), web and portfolio presence (15%), years of experience (15%), profile completeness (10%), and awards (up to 5 bonus points). There is no paid placement -- every ranking is purely editorial.
Who is the #1 home remodeling contractor in Middleton, WI?
As of 2026, Cards Property Maintenance holds the #1 ranking in Middleton with a Guide Score of 14/100. Rankings are recalculated with every data update and reflect the latest available information.
How often is this list updated?
Core data (ratings, reviews, contact information) is re-verified on a rolling monthly cadence. Credentials and awards are audited quarterly. Guide Scores recalculate automatically with every data update, so rankings may shift as new reviews are posted or credentials are verified.
How many home remodeling contractors are there in Middleton?
Our database currently tracks 16 active home remodeling contractors in the Middleton, WI metro area. This list highlights the top 15 based on Guide Score. Browse our full Middleton directory to see every listed business.
Can a home remodeling contractor pay to be ranked higher?
No. The Home Remodeling Guide does not accept payment for rankings. Guide Scores are computed algorithmically from verified public data. Businesses can claim and update their profile with accurate information, but the ranking algorithm treats all profiles equally. Our editorial independence is core to our methodology.
What should I look for when hiring a home remodeling contractor in Middleton?
We recommend evaluating: (1) professional certifications and credentials, (2) verified customer reviews and ratings, (3) years of experience in the Middleton market, (4) portfolio quality and range of work, (5) budget alignment with your project scope, and (6) responsiveness and communication style. Our Guide Score weighs these factors so you can compare at a glance.