Best Home Remodeling Contractors in Middleton, WI — 2026 Rankings

We ranked 18 home remodeling contractors in Middleton based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and portfolio quality.

How We Rank Home Remodeling Contractors

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CGR/CAPS/NARI (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). Read our full methodology →

Top Contractors in Middleton

  1. #1 — Cards Property Maintenance Score: 23/100

    Cards Property Maintenance | Professional Lawn & Property Maintenance in Madison & Middleton, WI

    Services: Quick Links, Our Services, Contact Us, Edging along walkways and driveways, String trimming around obstacles, Blowoff of hard surfaces, Flower bed preparation cleanup, Retains soil moisture, Spring fall application, Complete debris removal, Downspout clearing, Prevents foundation damage, Spring fall service, Complete leaf cleanup, Vacuum bag services, One Time or seasonal contracts, Proper disposal, Services, Gallery, Lawn Mowing, Mulching, Gutter Cleaning, Leaf Removal, Middleton, WI, 608 722 0709, [email protected]. View full profile →

  2. #2 — Stagecoach Plumbing, Inc. Score: 22/100

    Local Plumber in Middleton, WI

    Services: Emergency Plumbing, Residential Plumbing Services, New Construction Plumbing, Bathroom Kitchen Remodeling, Bathroom Remodeling, Kitchen Remodeling, Do You Offer Free Estimates?, What Should I Do in a Plumbing Emergency?, How Long Does a Bathroom Or Kitchen Remodel Take?, Do You Handle Plumbing for Small Businesses?, Can You Help With Water Heater Installation?, Plumbing Services, Feedback, Reviews, Fixture Repair and Replacement, Water Heater Installation, Sump Pump Installation, Leak Detection and Drain Repair, Water Softeners, Master Plumber Accreditation: Our Master Plumber Certification Ensures You’re Working With Highly Trained Professionals., Customer First Approach: We’re Committed to Making the Process Smooth and Stress Free, Whether It’s a Quick Fix Or a Major Remodel., Transparent Pricing: No Surprises Here—we Provide Clear, Upfront Estimates So You Know What to Expect.. View full profile →

  3. #3 — Madison Fence Company Score: 20/100

    Based in Middleton, WI, Madison Fence Company provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 7912 Forsythia Ct. Reach them at +16085152633. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  4. #4 — Phoenix Remodeling LLC Score: 19/100

    With a specialty in general contracting, Phoenix Remodeling LLC is a contractor proudly serving Middleton, ID.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  5. #5 — Aspen Contracting Score: 17/100

    Based in Middleton, WI, Aspen Contracting provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 5304 Valley Ridge Plz. Reach them at +16085042599. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  6. #6 — Larson Electric Score: 17/100

    As a contractor in Middleton, Larson Electric works with clients across the WI region. Reach them at +16082184522 or email info@larsonelectricmadison.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 7912 Forsythia Ct.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  7. #7 — McGarrity Painting LLC Score: 17/100

    Based in Middleton, WI, McGarrity Painting LLC provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Located at 6726 North Ave. Reach them at +16085137411. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  8. #8 — Access Door & More Score: 17/100

    Access Door & More, a contractor in Middleton, WI, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Reach them at +16082206571 or email accessdoorwi@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1817 Bristol St.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  9. #9 — Butler Landscaping Score: 17/100

    Serving homeowners and businesses in Middleton, Butler Landscaping is a dependable contractor in WI. Reach them at +17342721677 or email thebutlerlandscaping.service@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 3633 Napoli Ln.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  10. #10 — Dallman Plumbing LLC Score: 16/100

    Dallman Plumbing LLC has built a reputation for quality contracting work in the Middleton, WI area. Located at 2211 Parview Rd 5. Reach them at 6088411264. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  11. #11 — Struck & Irwin Fence Score: 16/100

    Struck & Irwin Fence is an established contractor serving the Middleton, WI community with professional contracting services. Located at 2830 Parmenter St. Reach them at 6082551673. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  12. #12 — DuraShield Roofing & Contracting Score: 16/100

    DuraShield Roofing & Contracting, a contractor in Middleton, WI, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Reach them at 6082213700. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 7800 Discovery Dr 3rd Floor. Reach them at 6082213700.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  13. #13 — Parks Electrical Service Inc Score: 16/100

    Parks Electrical Service Inc serves Middleton and surrounding WI communities with professional contracting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 7411 Voss Pkwy. Reach them at 6088365556. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  14. #14 — Superior Fence & Rail Score: 13/100

    Superior Fence & Rail brings professional contracting expertise to the Middleton, WI community. Located at 1600 N High Point Rd Ste 140. Reach them at 6084402889. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  15. #15 — Premier Painting and Contracting Score: 13/100

    Premier Painting and Contracting is a contractor firm serving Middleton and surrounding areas in WI. Reach them at +16083353335. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1402 Shady Oak Cir. Reach them at +16083353335.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  16. #16 — Alonso Landscape Service LLC Score: 13/100

    Alonso Landscape Service LLC is a trusted contractor proudly serving Middleton, WI and the surrounding region. Located at 2503 Pleasant View Rd. Reach them at 6083084908. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  17. #17 — Exterior Renovations, LLC Score: 13/100

    Connect with Exterior Renovations, LLC, a contractor proudly serving the Middleton, WI community. Call 6088361950 for a free consultation.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  18. #18 — Bar Diamond F Homes, LLC Score: 12/100

    Based in Middleton, ID, Bar Diamond F Homes, LLC provides comprehensive contracting services to residential and commercial clients throughout the region. Services include general contracting. Located at 22918 Duff Lane. Reach them at (208) 914-3618.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

Frequently asked questions

Who is the #1 home remodeling contractor in Middleton?

Cards Property Maintenance is currently the #1 ranked home remodeling contractor in Middleton based on our Guide Score. See the full ranked list above.

How are contractors ranked in Middleton?

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CGR/CAPS/NARI (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). There is no paid placement.

What do home remodeling projects typically cost in Middleton?

Costs vary by scope. Bathroom remodels in Middleton commonly run $15,000–$50,000; kitchen remodels $25,000–$100,000+; whole-home renovations start at $75,000 and can exceed $500,000. Each contractor profile lists their published budget tier.