Best Home Remodeling Contractors in Carnegie, PA — 2026 Rankings

We ranked 7 home remodeling contractors in Carnegie based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and portfolio quality.

How We Rank Home Remodeling Contractors

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CGR/CAPS/NARI (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). Read our full methodology →

Top Contractors in Carnegie

  1. #1 — L and M Roofing Score: 20/100

    The Carnegie, PA area is home to L and M Roofing, a dedicated contractor serving local clients. Reach them at +18884287663 or email info@landmroof.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 200 Keystone Dr.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  2. #2 — M J Flaherty Plumbing and Heating Score: 17/100

    M J Flaherty Plumbing and Heating is a Carnegie, PA contractor ready to help with your next project. Call +14122793224 or check out their website.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  3. #3 — Pittsburgh Fence Co Inc Score: 17/100

    Pittsburgh Fence Co Inc serves Carnegie and surrounding PA communities with professional contracting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 551 E Main St. Reach them at +14122764822. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  4. #4 — Quaker State Construction Score: 16/100

    Serving Carnegie and the surrounding PA region, Quaker State Construction is available at 4122763200. Visit their website for more information on their contracting services.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  5. #5 — Holzer Jesko Quality Exteriors Score: 13/100

    A contractor in the heart of Carnegie, Holzer Jesko Quality Exteriors is just a phone call away at 4123877785. Learn more on their website.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  6. #6 — Experts Garage Door Repair Installation Process Score: 13/100

    Experts Garage Door Repair Installation Process is a contractor serving the Carnegie, PA community. Reach them at 8888065616. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2200 Washington Pike. Reach them at 8888065616.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

  7. #7 — O'Donnell/Dean Exteriors Score: 13/100

    O'Donnell/Dean Exteriors has built a reputation for quality contracting work in the Carnegie, PA area. Located at 532 Carothers Ave. Reach them at 4122765242. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Contracting. View full profile →

Frequently asked questions

Who is the #1 home remodeling contractor in Carnegie?

L and M Roofing is currently the #1 ranked home remodeling contractor in Carnegie based on our Guide Score. See the full ranked list above.

How are contractors ranked in Carnegie?

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CGR/CAPS/NARI (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). There is no paid placement.

What do home remodeling projects typically cost in Carnegie?

Costs vary by scope. Bathroom remodels in Carnegie commonly run $15,000–$50,000; kitchen remodels $25,000–$100,000+; whole-home renovations start at $75,000 and can exceed $500,000. Each contractor profile lists their published budget tier.